- Vault puzzle: A two-player lock challenge where one explorer reads clues while the other works the vault mechanism.
- Core mechanic: Asymmetric information — only your partner can see the symbols that determine the correct combination.
- Best strategy: Establish a fixed naming system for symbols before touching the dial.
- Critical tip: Change one dial position at a time and confirm what your partner observes before continuing.
- Reward: Opening the vault unlocks the route forward and counts toward story progression.
How the Vault Puzzle Works
The vault puzzle in We Were Here Forever appears during the mid-game sections of the adventure, after the explorers have worked their way beyond the early Castle Rock chambers. True to the game's design, the puzzle splits information between the two players: one explorer stands at the vault door with the locking mechanism, while the other discovers the clues that reveal how the mechanism must be set.
This is one of the classic asymmetric challenges the series is known for. Neither player can solve it alone, and guessing is actively punished because incorrect attempts force you to retrace and verify every position. Success depends entirely on how precisely you describe what you see over the walkie-talkie.
The puzzle revolves around three elements:
| Element | Location | Who Can Access It |
|---|---|---|
| Vault door mechanism | At the vault | Player at the vault |
| Symbol and number clues | Nearby rooms and environmental details | The other explorer |
| Confirmation feedback | Changes visible on the mechanism | Both players, verbally |
Agree on names for every symbol you encounter — crown, eye, hook, key, spiral — and use those exact names for the entire puzzle. Switching descriptions halfway through is the most common cause of failed attempts.
Step-by-Step Vault Solution
Follow this sequence with your partner. Each step assumes clear walkie-talkie communication, which is the core mechanic of the game as confirmed on the official Steam store page.
Survey Both Sides
The explorer at the vault describes the mechanism: how many dials or positions it has, what symbols or markings appear on it, and how it can be manipulated. The other explorer reports every clue found nearby — markings, plaques, objects, and anything that looks like a sequence.
Match Clues to Dial Positions
Compare the clue symbols against the markings on the vault mechanism. Read the full expected sequence aloud before touching anything, then have your partner repeat it back for confirmation.
Set One Position at a Time
Adjust only one dial position at a time. After each change, the observing player confirms exactly what changed on their side. This keeps both explorers synchronized on the puzzle state.
Verify the Full Sequence
Before committing, read the complete set position back one final time. A single transposed symbol means starting the verification over, so the extra ten seconds is worth it.
Open the Vault
Confirm the sequence together and trigger the mechanism. If the vault does not open, return to Step 2 and re-verify each clue rather than randomly changing positions.
Do not let both players experiment with the mechanism at once, and never change multiple dials between confirmations. When the puzzle state becomes unclear, reset to the beginning and rebuild the sequence from the original clues.
Communication Methods Compared
The vault puzzle is really a communication test. Different description styles lead to very different solve times:
| Method | Speed | Accuracy | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clock-face positions | Fast | High | Dial and rotational mechanisms |
| Named symbols (crown, eye, hook) | Fast | High | Symbol-heavy locks like the vault |
| Vague descriptions ("the swirly one") | Slow | Low | Avoid entirely |
| Reading full sequence first, then acting | Medium | Highest | Multi-part locks under pressure |
| Trial and error | Slowest | Very low | Not recommended |
Describe Position First
- State location before appearance
- Use "top-left," "second from the right"
- Prevents mix-ups between similar symbols
One Change, One Report
- Single change per turn
- Partner confirms the result
- Keeps puzzle state clear for both players
Countdown for Actions
- Agree before acting together
- Use short words: ready, go, stop, reset
- Essential for any timed mechanism nearby
Establishing a shared vocabulary early in your run pays off beyond the vault — later areas beneath the frozen surface demand even longer chains of cooperative actions, and consistent naming habits carry over directly.
Troubleshooting a Stuck Vault
If the vault refuses to open, work through these checks in order:
| Symptom | Likely Cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Dial set but nothing happens | A clue was misdescribed | Re-read every clue and re-name each symbol |
| Partner describes different markings | Symbols exist in multiple rooms | Confirm which clue set belongs to the vault |
| Sequence resets after attempts | An incorrect entry was committed | Verify the full sequence before triggering |
| Missing clue entirely | An interactive object was overlooked | Search side rooms and less obvious surfaces |
Vault Puzzle Checklist:
- Both players described their full surroundings
- Every symbol has an agreed name
- Full sequence read aloud and repeated back
- Only one dial position changed per turn
- Final verification completed before opening
If progress still stops, retrace the entire current area together. In We Were Here Forever, missing information is usually one player overlooking an object, symbol, or environmental detail — not a wrong solution.
FAQ
Q: Can the We Were Here Forever vault puzzle be solved by one player?
No. Like the rest of the game, the vault puzzle is built around two-player asymmetric information — the clues and the mechanism are split between the explorers, so a partner is required.
Q: What if we enter the wrong vault sequence?
Re-verify the clues from the beginning rather than randomly changing dials. Read the full expected sequence aloud, repeat it back, and set each position one at a time with confirmation after every change.
Q: How long does the vault puzzle usually take?
With clear communication and a consistent symbol-naming system, most pairs solve it in well under 20 minutes. Vague descriptions are the main thing that drags the solve time out.
Q: Is the vault puzzle required for story progression?
Yes. Opening the vault is part of advancing through the mid-game region, and completing it contributes to the story-progression achievements on the way through the adventure.